Of the list, I only know Ghostories and I can't recommend it enough. It's a very refreshing take on the genre without being "Yet Another Lovecraft RPG!".
Brett Commented:
Oct 18, 2013 | 5:50 pm
It got a bad review for not being Call of Cthulhu ;)
skathros Commented:
Oct 18, 2013 | 7:33 pm
That's funny. Call of Cthulhu does Cthulhu pretty well...as does Trail of Cthulhu...as does Macabre Tales...as does...hmmmm...really, do we need another game doing Cthulhu? And one thing GS has that those Cthulhu games don't is the ability to run it under various sub-genres. Nomal folks investigating the supernatural? GS has you covered! Ghostbusting fun? GS has you covered! PCs tied to the supernatural? GS has you covered! The game has a much wider range. Don't get me wrong, I love me some Cthulhu (Macabre Tales is my poison of choice for such), but GS cover a lot more ground...and it's just plain old fun (kinda like Beyond the Supernatural was fun).